top of page
  • instagram-256
  • Youtube
Illustrated woman beside her partner at a cafe glancing at a laughing couple

Relationship OCD and Comparing: 7 Real Signs It Has Become a Compulsion

Writer: India Haylor
India Haylor
22 minutes ago
12 min read

You are at a friend's wedding and the best man gives a funny, easy speech. Within seconds your mind has lined him up next to your partner. Would your partner have been that relaxed? That quick? By the time the cake is cut you have replayed three conversations from last month, ranked your partner against two exes, and decided you need to look up whether this is normal. This is how relationship OCD and comparing often show up together. The comparison feels like a sensible check on a big decision. In practice it works as a compulsion, and it keeps the doubt going.

Quick answer: In relationship OCD (often shortened to ROCD), comparing means repeatedly measuring your partner, your feelings or your relationship against someone or something else. That might be an ex, a friend's partner, a colleague, a couple on social media, a character in a film, or an ideal partner you carry around in your head. Researchers who study ROCD list comparing as one of its common compulsions. It brings brief relief, then the doubt comes back. Treatment is the same as for other OCD: CBT with exposure and response prevention (ERP), which helps you notice the urge to compare and stop acting on it. Treatment does not decide for you whether to stay or leave.

Why relationship OCD and comparing go hand in hand

OCD has two parts. The NHS describes an obsession as an unwanted and unpleasant thought, image or urge that repeatedly enters your mind, and a compulsion as a repetitive behaviour or mental act you feel you need to do to temporarily relieve the feelings the obsession brings. Relationship OCD is OCD where those obsessions centre on a close relationship. It is not a separate diagnosis. The researchers behind ROCD.net, Professor Guy Doron and Dr Danny Derby, say that when the criteria are met, "it is diagnosed as OCD".

Comparing fits the obsession almost perfectly. If the fear is "What if I could do better?" or "What if this is not love?", the obvious way to check seems to be to measure. You hold your partner up against someone else and look for the answer. In their article for the International OCD Foundation, Doron and Derby describe a man called Jeffery who "looks at other women, listens to them, and compares them to his wife." He cannot stop thinking that he could have found a better partner.

Their list of ROCD compulsions includes "comparing their relationships with other people's relationships, such as friends, colleagues, or even characters in romantic films or TV sitcoms." A 2016 study by the same research group, published in Frontiers in Psychiatry, names "comparisons of partner's characteristics with those of other potential partners" alongside monitoring your own feelings, neutralising and reassurance seeking.

So if relationship OCD keeps comparing your partner with everyone you meet, you are not uniquely shallow or ungrateful. You are doing something researchers have described again and again in people with this form of OCD. That same study also found that the people with ROCD in their sample had symptoms as severe as the people with other forms of OCD. This is not a small worry to brush off.

The two sides of ROCD, and what each one compares

Doron and Derby describe two main presentations. They often overlap, and each tends to have its own favourite comparisons.

Relationship-centred doubts are about the relationship and your feelings. "Is this the right relationship for me?" "Does my partner really love me?" Here the comparison is often with your own past feelings, with an ex, or with the kind of love you see in films. Ran Littman, a psychologist who writes about ROCD for Psychology Today, lists "comparing one's feelings toward their partner to the feelings they had toward past partners" as a common hidden compulsion.

Partner-focused doubts fix on a perceived flaw in your partner. The 2016 study describes a "disabling preoccupation with perceived deficits of the relationship partner" in areas such as "appearance, intelligence, sociability, and morality". On this side of ROCD, the comparison is usually one feature set against someone else's: your partner's nose against a colleague's, their jokes against the best man's, their career against your friend's husband's.

ROCD.net makes a point many people find a relief to read: "The trait may be real. What marks ROCD is the repeated preoccupation with it and the need to keep checking what it means." Your partner may well be quieter at parties than your friend's partner. The trouble is the hours spent measuring it.

The two sides feed each other. A flaw you keep noticing makes you doubt the relationship, and doubting the relationship sends you looking for flaws. Comparing sits in the middle of both.

7 signs comparing has become a compulsion

Everyone compares sometimes. Noticing that your friend's partner is a great cook is ordinary. The signs below are how relationship OCD and comparing tend to look in everyday life when the comparing has become part of an OCD cycle. They are not a diagnosis. Only a proper assessment can tell you what is going on.

1. You keep coming back to the same feature

The comparison is not a passing thought. It is the same nose, the same laugh, the same level of ambition, checked over and over. In a guide for Psyche, clinical psychologist Marisa T Mazza writes that ROCD "often fixates on minor details, such as a physical feature or awkward laugh." If you could name the exact feature you have compared a hundred times, that repetition is worth noticing.

2. Exes become the measuring stick

You replay how you felt on dates years ago and compare it with how you feel now, on a Tuesday evening on the sofa. The early excitement of a past relationship becomes the standard your current one has to meet. Doron and Derby note that ROCD can also fix on past relationships, including your partner's. Their example worry is "Was their previous partner more successful/smart/funny/good looking than me?"

3. Other couples and screens feel like tests

Scrolling past a friend's anniversary post leaves you asking why your relationship does not look like that. A romantic film ends and you check whether you feel the same rush as the characters. The IOCDF article describes people who avoid romantic films for fear of not feeling love as strong or passionate as the characters do. Some avoid friends who seem to have a perfect relationship for the same reason. Avoidance and comparing are two sides of the same fear.

4. Meeting an attractive or impressive person sets off hours of analysis

A new colleague is funny and confident. That evening you are still turning it over. Does finding them interesting mean you are with the wrong person? Doron and Derby write that "encountering potential alternative partners may lead to intense distress and trigger preoccupation." People with partner-focused obsessions, they add, "may be particularly sensitive to the way their partner compares with others".

5. You run the comparison after the event

Littman calls this post-processing. His example is "re-analyzing the way a partner socialized with others at a party to figure out if he sounded smart enough". The party ended hours ago, but you are still replaying it, scoring your partner against everyone else in the room. Because it all happens in your head, the people around you may have no idea.

6. You test or correct your partner

Comparing can spill into behaviour. You steer a conversation to see whether your partner knows something your colleague knew. You suggest they dress, speak or laugh differently so they match a picture in your head. Doron and Derby list testing a partner to see whether they are intelligent enough, and trying to correct the partner to fit the obsessional need, which they call "just righting".

7. The relief never lasts

Sometimes the comparison goes in your partner's favour and you feel lighter. Then a new person, a new film or a new memory comes along and you are back at the start. The NHS describes this pattern for all OCD: the compulsion temporarily relieves the anxiety, but the obsession and anxiety soon return and the cycle begins again. If your comparing has never once settled the question for good, that is the cycle at work.

Why comparing never settles the doubt

Comparing feels like research. It looks like the sensible thing to do before a big decision. For someone with ROCD there are a few reasons it does not work, and why relationship OCD and comparing get stuck in a loop.

There is always another comparison. Somewhere there is always someone funnier, kinder, better looking or more successful, and OCD will find them. A partner cannot win a contest that never ends.

Comparing also makes the thought feel more important. Littman writes that "the more people react to their obsessive thoughts, the more meaningful and persistent these thoughts become." Each comparison tells your brain that this question is urgent and dangerous, so it brings the question back more often.

The standard keeps moving too. Doron and Derby describe people with ROCD holding beliefs such as "If the relationship is not completely perfect, it is unlikely to be 'true love'". In their 2016 study, people with ROCD scored higher than both people with other OCD and people without OCD on beliefs about how bad it would be to be in the wrong relationship. If a relationship has to be perfect to count, every comparison will find a gap.

We see the same pattern across every theme of OCD. Certainty is the thing OCD asks for and the one thing nobody can give. Our founder wrote about this in The absurdity of certainty!, and it applies to love as much as anything else.

Comparing, ordinary doubt, or a relationship that is wrong for you

This is the question most people with ROCD want answered first, so here is the honest answer. No blog post can tell you whether your relationship is right. ROCD.net says ROCD "describes how a person responds to doubt." It "cannot tell anyone whether a particular relationship is right."

What can help is looking at how the doubt behaves.

  • Urgency. Mazza writes that "if you are currently in a desperate search for a definitive answer, that urgency is often a sign of ROCD." Doubts about a relationship that is not working usually feel slower and heavier. She describes "a more persistent, heavy sadness that lacks that frantic edge."

  • Detail. OCD tends to fix on small things, like a laugh or a feature, more than on how you are treated day to day.

  • Swings. One evening you feel sure, the next morning you feel nothing. In Mazza's words, "OCD doubt is volatile."

  • Purpose. If you are comparing to calm a spike of anxiety, it is working as a compulsion. If you are thinking through a concrete problem, like a disagreement about where to live or whether to have children, that is ordinary decision making.

One more point matters a great deal. ROCD.net states that "Violence, threats, coercion or control in a relationship are not ROCD symptoms." If you feel unsafe with your partner, that is not OCD, and you deserve support from your GP or a domestic abuse service. In an emergency, call 999.

How ERP helps with relationship OCD and comparing

ROCD is treated as OCD. ROCD.net says it is treated "with cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT) that includes exposure and response prevention (ERP)" and that treatment "aims to reduce checking, comparing and reassurance-seeking". It adds that treatment "does not aim to persuade anyone to stay in a relationship or to leave it." The IOCDF article sets out a similar goal: helping people reach a decision about their relationship "based on their experience of it, rather than based on ROCD-related fears."

On the NHS, therapy for OCD is usually CBT with ERP. The NHS treatment page says people with fairly mild OCD usually need about 8 to 20 sessions, with exercises done at home between sessions, and that more severe OCD may need a longer course.

In practice, ERP for comparing might include:

  • Looking at a photo of an attractive person or a friend's partner on purpose, noticing the urge to compare, and not doing the comparison.

  • Watching a romantic film all the way through without checking your feelings against the characters'.

  • Writing a short script of the feared thought, such as "I might be settling for second best", and reading it without arguing back.

  • Going to a party and, afterwards, not replaying how your partner came across.

  • Turning toward your partner in a small moment, such as asking about their day, instead of analysing them. Mazza gives a similar example of an in vivo exposure.

The exercises ask you to let the doubt stay without doing anything to settle it. The aim is for the doubt to bother you less over time, even if it still turns up now and then. Mazza also names acceptance and commitment therapy (ACT) and inference-based CBT as evidence-supported approaches that can be used alongside or instead of ERP.

Exposure should be planned with a therapist who knows OCD. Done badly, it can turn into another way of checking. Our post on ERP therapy in the UK explains what good ERP looks like and what to ask before you start.

Things you can start trying this week

These do not replace treatment, but they follow the same logic, and they suit relationship OCD and comparing in particular.

  1. Name it. When you catch yourself measuring, say to yourself "that's comparing" and leave it there. Littman describes recognising your compulsions as an early step in treating ROCD.

  2. Delay it. If the urge to compare is strong, tell yourself you can do it in 20 minutes, then carry on with what you were doing. Notice what happens to the urge while you wait.

  3. Stop the research. Put down the online quizzes and the articles about whether your relationship is right. Mazza lists searching the internet or asking AI for answers among ROCD compulsions.

  4. Do not confess every comparison. Telling your partner each time you compared them is a form of reassurance seeking. Littman lists repeatedly confessing doubts among the visible compulsions of ROCD. Our post Don't reassure me! explains why reassurance backfires.

  5. Put your attention on the moment. When you are with your partner, focus on what you are doing together rather than on scoring them. Littman lists refocusing attention among the tools he teaches clients.

  6. Keep big decisions out of a spike. OCD-UK notes that the constant analysing and questioning can lead people to end a relationship to get rid of the doubt and anxiety, and that the cycle is often repeated in the next relationship. If you want to make a big decision, make it with support, not at 2am in the middle of a spike.

If you are the partner being compared

If your partner lives with relationship OCD and comparing is part of it, you may be hurt and confused. Being compared stings, even when you know where it comes from. A few things help.

  • Remember that the comparisons come from the disorder. They say more about how OCD works than about your worth.

  • Try not to compete. Proving you are as clever as their colleague or as fun as their ex keeps the testing going.

  • Answer reassurance requests kindly but briefly, and agree together, ideally with their therapist, how you will handle them. Our guide to family accommodation in OCD covers this in detail.

  • Look after yourself too. Our support for family and carers page and our post on dating someone with OCD have more ideas.

Getting help for ROCD in the UK

You do not need to be sure what is going on before you ask for help. ROCD.net puts it simply: "You do not need to settle the question about your relationship before you seek help." On the NHS, you can refer yourself directly to an NHS talking therapies service, or see a GP who can refer you.

If you go privately, look for a therapist who treats OCD as a specialism, uses ERP, and understands relationship OCD and comparing compulsions. A therapist who helps you weigh up your partner's qualities session after session is, without meaning to, joining in with the compulsion.

At OCD Excellence, our practice is 100% OCD-focused, and nearly every therapist on the team has lived experience of OCD. One of our senior therapists, Emma, moved into therapy after her own treatment for responsibility and relationship OCD in her early twenties. Our founder, India Haylor, has worked in OCD since 2003.

An assessment with a senior therapist starts at £150 for 50 minutes, and regular sessions cost from £60 to £100 depending on the therapist. We also run Zoom workshops on themes including ROCD. For more background, read our earlier post, Relationship OCD (ROCD): Hidden in Plain Sight.

Frequently asked questions about relationship OCD and comparing

Is it normal to compare my partner to other people?

Now and then, yes. Doron and Derby write that it is very common for people to have some doubts about whether their partner is right for them. Littman describes behaviours becoming compulsions when they are used repeatedly, take up a lot of time, and are done to get rid of unwanted thoughts and feelings. If that describes your comparing, it is worth speaking to someone.

Does comparing my partner to my ex mean I should go back to them?

Not by itself. Comparing how you feel now with how you felt about past partners is a recognised ROCD compulsion. OCD tends to pick the most flattering memory to measure against. A therapist can help you tell an OCD comparison apart from a considered decision.

Can ROCD happen when I am single?

Yes. The IOCDF article notes that ROCD symptoms can occur outside an ongoing relationship, for example fixing on ex-partners. Comparing can also follow people into dating, where each new person is measured against an ideal.

Will treatment stop me noticing attractive people?

No, and it is not meant to. Noticing other people is ordinary. Treatment helps you notice, let the thought pass, and skip the hours of analysis that usually follow.

Is ROCD an official diagnosis?

No. ROCD.net explains that ROCD is not a separate category in the DSM-5-TR. It is a way of describing OCD that centres on a relationship, and it is diagnosed and treated as OCD.

What if the comparing is making me feel low or hopeless?

That is common, and you should tell someone. In the 2016 study, people with ROCD had more severe depression symptoms than people without OCD. Speak to your GP. If you are having thoughts of ending your life, call 999 in an emergency or call Samaritans free on 116 123, day or night.

Next steps

Relationship OCD and comparing make a tiring pair. Each comparison promises an answer and hands you a new question instead. The way out is learning to leave the question open while you get on with your life and your relationship, and that can be learned with the right help.

If you recognise yourself in this post, you can book an assessment with one of our OCD therapists, many of whom have been where you are. You can also read more about our founder, India Haylor, on the about page.

If you are in crisis or feel at risk of harming yourself, call 999, go to your nearest emergency department, or call Samaritans free on 116 123.

Comments


Recent Posts

READY TO START?

Take Your First
Step Today

Whether you're ready to book an assessment or still figuring out if this is right for you we're here. Start with our free OCD quiz or speak to the team directly.

bottom of page