top of page
  • instagram-256
  • Youtube
Young man on a bench looking worriedly up at a crescent moon and stars

Existential OCD: 7 Real Signs Your Big Questions Have Become Obsessions

Writer: India Haylor
India Haylor
10 minutes ago
12 min read

Most people have wondered at some point whether life has a point, what happens when we die, or how they can be sure the world around them is real. They think about it for a while, maybe talk it over with a friend, then go and make a cup of tea. With existential OCD, the question does not let go. It turns up when you wake, follows you through work, and keeps you up at night. Every answer you find seems to help for a few minutes, then a new doubt appears and the whole thing starts again.

Quick answer: Existential OCD is a common name for OCD that fixes on big questions with no final answer, such as "Why do I exist?", "What if nothing is real?" or "What is the point if we all die?". The questions feel urgent and frightening, and people try to settle them with mental compulsions: analysing, researching, debating, checking their own perception and seeking reassurance. Those compulsions keep the cycle going. It responds to the same treatment as other kinds of OCD, which is CBT with exposure and response prevention (ERP), sometimes alongside medication. The aim is not to find the answer. It is to stop needing one.

What existential OCD is

OCD has two parts. The NHS describes an obsession as an unwanted thought, image or urge that keeps coming back, and a compulsion as a repeated behaviour or mental act you feel you have to do to get temporary relief. In existential OCD, the obsession is a question about life, reality, death, the self or the universe.

Fred Penzel, PhD, writing for the International OCD Foundation, defines it as "intrusive, repetitive thinking about questions which cannot possibly be answered". He adds that the questions may be philosophical or frightening, or both, and usually revolve around the meaning, purpose or reality of life, the existence of the universe, or even your own existence. He also calls it "Philosophical OCD".

It helps to know that existential OCD is not an official diagnosis on its own. The writer Lily Bailey, in a first-person piece for Psychology Today, says there is no separate "existential OCD" and that the label is more a useful way of describing one obsessional theme. That matters, because it means everything known about treating OCD applies here too. You do not need a special therapy for a special subtype. You need good OCD treatment, from someone who recognises the theme for what it is.

How common is it? Nobody has a reliable figure for this theme on its own, and we will not guess. What we do know is that OCD as a whole is not rare. OCD-UK puts it at around 1.2% of the population, or around three quarters of a million people in the UK at any one time. Some of those people will have existential themes, sometimes alongside other fears.

At OCD Excellence this theme is close to home. Our founder, India Haylor, has lived with what she calls Metaphysical OCD since she was 11, and nearly every therapist on our team has their own lived experience of OCD. We know how lonely it can feel to have a fear that sounds, to other people, like an interesting late-night conversation.

7 signs your big questions have become obsessions

Thinking about life and death is part of being human. Philosophers have built careers on it. The difference with OCD is not the topic. It is how the thought behaves, how it feels and what you do about it. Here are seven signs that point towards OCD rather than ordinary curiosity. They are not a diagnosis, and only a proper assessment can tell you what is going on for you.

1. You cannot put the question down

Penzel points out that people can leave a philosophy or physics class, read about these ideas and move on with a shrug. People with existential OCD cannot just drop the question. If you have tried hard to stop thinking about it and the thought comes straight back, often stronger, that is worth noticing.

2. The question brings fear, not interest

Curiosity feels open. An obsession feels like a threat. If the thought "What if none of this is real?" comes with a jolt of panic, a sick feeling or a sense that something terrible will happen unless you sort it out, it is behaving like an obsession.

3. Every answer wears off

You read an article, find a good argument or hear a reassuring view, and for a short time you feel better. Then a new doubt arrives, often a small twist on the old one. Penzel writes that there are never any lasting answers to obsessive questions, and that answers last a few minutes before new doubts appear that are mostly variations on a theme.

4. You spend hours on it

Many people with this theme lose whole evenings to going over the same question. Penzel describes people spending hours going over these questions and becoming extremely anxious and depressed. If the time it takes is getting in the way of sleep, work, study or relationships, that is a sign it has gone beyond normal reflection.

5. You check your own experience

Some people stare in the mirror and ask whether that is really them. Others test whether their feelings are their own, or watch their partner and children and wonder if they are real. Penzel gives the example of a young man who spends hours at the mirror asking "Is this really me? How do I know?". Checking your own perception is a compulsion, even though nobody else can see it.

6. You avoid things that set it off

You might skip films about dreams or simulations, stop looking at the night sky, steer away from funerals or change the subject when someone mentions space. Avoidance feels like protection, but it teaches your brain that the thought is dangerous.

7. The thoughts make life feel pointless

A common loop runs like this: "If we all die anyway, what is the use of doing anything?". Penzel uses almost exactly those words in one of his examples. When the thought starts to drain the colour out of things you used to enjoy, OCD and low mood can feed each other. Our post on OCD and depression covers how that cycle works.

The compulsions you might not notice

Because so much of existential OCD happens in your head, people often believe they have no compulsions at all. This is one reason the older label "Pure O" is misleading. OCD-UK calls the term "both unhelpful and imprecise", and our own post on Pure OCD explains why.

Here are compulsions that are common with this theme. Many come from the list Patricia Zurita Ona, PsyD, gives in Lily Bailey's Psychology Today article, and the rest from Penzel.

  • Going over the question in your head, trying to reason your way to an answer.

  • Reading philosophy, physics or religious texts to settle the doubt.

  • Searching online, often late at night, for proof that reality is real or that life has meaning.

  • Talking the topic through with friends or family as a way of "figuring it out".

  • Asking people whether they think the world is real, or whether they feel the same.

  • Replaying memories or emotional moments to check that they felt real.

  • Testing your senses, for example pinching yourself or staring at objects.

  • Telling yourself comforting lines over and over, which is a form of self-reassurance.

  • Trying to push the thought away or replace it with a "safe" one.

OCD-UK describes how reassurance works: once is never enough, and each time you seek it you strengthen the need to seek it again. Our older post, Don't reassure me!, explains why reassurance feels so helpful and does so much harm in OCD.

Why the answers never stick

People with existential OCD are often thoughtful, bright and good at arguing. That can make the problem worse. When a question cannot be answered, a good mind simply builds a better argument, and OCD replies with a better doubt.

Penzel puts it bluntly. Obsessive doubts cannot be argued with, reasoned out, analysed or questioned. He says trying to find answers or push the thoughts away are the worst ways to deal with OCD. He also explains the paradox at the centre of it: the more you tell yourself not to think something, the more you think of it.

The questions at the heart of this theme have one thing in common. Nobody can be certain of the answer. Not philosophers, not scientists, not your therapist. Most people live with that uncertainty without noticing it. OCD makes the uncertainty feel intolerable, then offers thinking as the way out. Every round of thinking brings a moment of relief, and that relief is what keeps you coming back.

We have written before about why chasing certainty is a losing game in The absurdity of certainty!. With existential OCD the point is even sharper, because the certainty you want does not exist for anyone.

How existential concerns link to other OCD fears

Existential worries do not only turn up as a standalone theme. A 2022 study by Chawla, Menzies and Menzies in the Journal of Obsessive-Compulsive and Related Disorders looked at 48 adults with OCD who were seeking treatment. Simply Psychology's summary of the study reports that five existential concerns (death anxiety, meaninglessness, isolation, identity and guilt) were all linked to how severe a person's OCD was, and all but isolation stayed linked after the researchers controlled for neuroticism.

The study also found that fear of death was linked to aggressive, harm-type obsessions, while concerns about identity, meaninglessness and guilt were linked to sexual obsessions. The authors suggest that standard treatment may not always reach these underlying fears, and that this might be one reason some people keep coming back for more treatment.

It was a small study and it cannot prove cause and effect, so we would not read too much into it. It does fit what we often see in the therapy room. Someone may come in for harm OCD or relationship OCD, and underneath sits a fear about death, meaning or who they really are. A good assessment should look for those threads.

Existential OCD or something else?

Big questions can come up in several conditions, so it is worth thinking about what else could be going on. This section is for information only. It is not a way to diagnose yourself.

  • Depression. Low mood can bring heavy thoughts about meaning and death. Penzel notes that existential OCD can be confused with depressive rumination, but says it is far more complicated. The two can also happen together.

  • Generalised anxiety. Penzel says existential OCD is sometimes misdiagnosed as Generalised Anxiety Disorder. The OCD pattern tends to be one repeated theme, with compulsions aimed at settling it.

  • Feeling detached or unreal. Some people describe a sense that the world looks flat or dreamlike. Asking "what if nothing is real?" is not the same as experiencing the world as unreal, and a professional can help tell these apart.

  • Ordinary reflection. If you enjoy thinking about these questions, can stop when you choose, and they do not frighten you, that sounds like ordinary human curiosity.

Penzel offers a useful cue. If the thoughts are intrusive, repetitive, persistent, anxiety-producing and full of doubt, it is most likely existential OCD.

Please speak to your GP the same day, rather than waiting for an OCD assessment, if you are seeing or hearing things other people do not, if you feel your thoughts are being controlled from outside, or if questions about death have turned into thoughts of ending your life.

How existential OCD is treated

The NHS says that therapy for OCD is usually a type of cognitive behavioural therapy (CBT) with exposure and response prevention (ERP). People with fairly mild OCD usually need about 8 to 20 sessions, with exercises done at home between sessions, and people with more severe OCD may need longer.

Medication can help too. The NHS says you may need medicine if therapy does not help or your OCD is fairly severe, usually an SSRI antidepressant, and that it can take up to 12 weeks to notice a benefit. Medication decisions belong with your GP or psychiatrist, and you should not stop an SSRI without speaking to your doctor first. Penzel's view is that medication makes it easier to do the therapy, and the therapy is what changes you.

ERP for existential OCD works on the same idea as ERP for contamination or checking. You face the thing you fear, a little at a time, and you stop doing the compulsions that bring short-term relief. The difference is that the feared thing here is a thought and the uncertainty around it, so exposure is mostly done with words, images, places and media rather than door handles or light switches.

Penzel sums up the approach in one line: "If you want to think about it less, think about it more." That sounds wrong at first. In practice it means choosing to bring the thought on deliberately, on your terms, instead of fighting it every time it shows up.

If you want to know more about what good ERP looks like before you start, our guide to ERP therapy in the UK covers the basics, and CBT for OCD explains how OCD-specific CBT differs from the general kind.

What exposure can look like for existential fears

Every plan should be built with a therapist and set at a level you can manage. To give you a picture, here are the kinds of exercises Penzel describes for this theme.

  1. Writing the feared sentence. For example, writing "Nothing is real" or "I will never get answers to my questions" many times a day, until it becomes boring. Penzel notes that you cannot be bored and scared at the same time.

  2. Short recordings. Recording a two-minute script that says the feared idea is true, then listening to it several times a day, with the scripts getting harder over time.

  3. Notes around the house. Small signs with the feared thought on them, placed where you will see them.

  4. Agreeing with the thought. Instead of arguing back, answering the doubt with something like "Maybe nothing is real, and maybe I will never know".

  5. Films and reading. Watching films built around dreams or simulated worlds, such as Inception, or reading articles that agree with the fear rather than ones that disprove it.

  6. Going to trigger places. Visiting places that bring the thoughts on, instead of avoiding them.

The response prevention side matters just as much. That means no arguing, analysing or questioning the thought, no reassurance from yourself or anyone else, no searching for articles that disprove it, and no talking the topic through as a way of settling it.

Penzel also lists some things that are worth accepting along the way: that you have OCD, that there is no real explanation for why you have these thoughts, that there are no real answers to the questions, and that the thoughts can be lived with. That last point is where recovery tends to start.

Some therapists also use acceptance and commitment therapy (ACT) skills alongside ERP, which focus on making room for the thought and acting on what you care about anyway. The Chawla study summary mentions that approaches aimed at existential fears, such as an online CBT programme for death anxiety, may sit alongside ERP. These are additions to ERP, not replacements.

Getting help in the UK

Most of the top results for existential OCD come from the United States, which is not much use if you live in Britain. Here is what the route looks like here.

  • NHS talking therapies. The NHS says you can refer yourself directly to an NHS talking therapies service, or see your GP, who can refer you. Waiting times vary by area.

  • Specialist NHS services. The NHS says some people with severe, long-term and hard-to-treat OCD may be referred to a national specialist OCD service.

  • Charities. OCD-UK and OCD Action both offer information and can tell you about support groups.

  • Private specialist therapy. If you choose to go private, look for someone who works mainly with OCD and uses ERP. Ask how they would treat mental compulsions, and be wary of anyone who wants to spend sessions debating the meaning of life with you. That can turn therapy into one more compulsion.

At OCD Excellence we only treat OCD. You can read about how we work with people with OCD, and our assessments start from £150 for 50 minutes with a senior therapist. An assessment looks at whether OCD is present, how severe it is, the main and secondary themes, and anything else that may be going on, then sets out a treatment plan.

If you are waiting for help, our post on hope for OCD may be worth reading, especially if you have tried treatment before and it did not work.

Frequently asked questions

Is existential OCD a real diagnosis?

The diagnosis is OCD. "Existential OCD" is a description of what the obsessions are about. That is good news, because it means the treatment for OCD in general, CBT with ERP, applies to this theme as well.

Can existential OCD go away on its own?

We cannot say how it will go for any one person. The NHS says it is unlikely OCD will get better without proper treatment and support. Thoughts about meaning and reality can ease for a while and then return when life gets stressful, which is another reason to get proper treatment rather than wait.

Should my therapist try to answer my questions about life and death?

Not as a way of treating OCD. Answers are a form of reassurance, and Penzel lists reassurance as a compulsion to stop. A good OCD therapist will help you live with the question unanswered, rather than help you hunt for the answer.

Is it normal to think about death and the meaning of life?

Yes. Almost everyone does at some point. The question is how the thought behaves. If you can think about it and then get on with your day, that is ordinary reflection. If it takes hours, frightens you and drives you to check, research and seek reassurance, it may be OCD.

Can children and teenagers get existential OCD?

The NHS says OCD symptoms can start from as early as 6, though it often begins around puberty and early adulthood. Our founder's own Metaphysical OCD started at 11. If you are a parent, look out for repeated, anxious questions about death or reality and for a need to be reassured again and again.

What if the thoughts make me feel hopeless?

Please tell someone. Thoughts about meaninglessness can drag your mood down hard. If you are having thoughts of ending your life, speak to your GP today, call NHS 111, or call the Samaritans on 116 123 at any time.

Next steps

Existential OCD takes the oldest questions people ask and turns them into a trap. The questions themselves are not the problem. The need to answer them, right now and for certain, is what keeps you stuck. Treatment does not hand you an answer about the universe. It helps you get your time, sleep and attention back while the question stays open.

If you recognise yourself in this post, you can book an assessment with one of our OCD therapists, many of whom have been where you are. You can also find out more about our founder, India Haylor, on the about page.

If you are in crisis or feel at risk of harming yourself, call 999, go to your nearest emergency department, or call the Samaritans free on 116 123.

Comments


Recent Posts

READY TO START?

Take Your First
Step Today

Whether you're ready to book an assessment or still figuring out if this is right for you we're here. Start with our free OCD quiz or speak to the team directly.

bottom of page